Hire Movers in Shelter Island
Looking for the best local movers in Shelter Island? HireAHelper has been curating the highest-rated Shelter Island moving companies and day laborers in every city in New York for more than 16 years.
Compare the Top 4 Shelter Island, NY Movers
According to thousands of honest reviews in your area, these are the top-rated movers as of Sunday, February 2, 2025.
$125/hr
After 2 movers 2 hr minA Plus Moving LLC
East Haven, CT
1,299 moves with HireAHelper
$119/hr
After 2 movers 2 hr minMakin Moves
Rocky Point, NY
1,194 moves with HireAHelper
$120/hr
After 2 movers 2 hr minFirst Class Movers, LLC
New Haven, CT
457 moves with HireAHelper
$80/hr
After 2 movers 2 hr minReady To Move
Middletown, CT
124 moves with HireAHelper
Shelter Island Mover Reviews
Very nice guys. They worked hard, being very careful not to scratch the items nor my floors. Very polite. I would use them again. Thank you guys!
Vinnie and his team worked hard to complete my job in a timely manner despite an unexpected staff call-off. They were very friendly and well organized.
They were efficient, careful and completed the job exactly as needed. Would hire them again.
Guys we’re on time ready to work. Both did a terrific job! Hard working guys. We really appreciated their help.
Local Moving Resources for Shelter Island
HireAHelper compiles data from hundreds of moves in the greater Shelter Island area to share with you, so you can have accurate, up-to-the-minute timelines and prices for New York movers near you.
Avg. Shelter Island move books:
Avg. Shelter Island move takes:
Frequently asked moving questions in Shelter Island
When is it cheapest to move in Shelter Island?
January
Of all months of the year, the cheapest time to move in Shelter Island is January. Get your personalized moving quote.
What day is it cheaper to move in Shelter Island?
Monday
Monday is the cheapest day to move in Shelter Island.
The best time of day to move in Shelter Island is...
9 AM - 10 AM
People who save the most on their move in Shelter Island started it at 9 AM - 10 AM.
How far in advance should I schedule my appointment?
12 days
People in Shelter Island tend to book their move at least 12 days in advance.
How much do movers in Shelter Island cost?
$531
Hiring a moving company in Shelter Island costs $531 on average.
How long does moving in Shelter Island take?
4 hours
Shelter Island movers take 4 hours per job, on average. Check the best times to move in Shelter Island.
How many movers do I need for my move in Shelter Island?
2 movers
Most people moving in Shelter Island hire 2 movers to come out on moving day. Read more about hiring the right number of movers.
What size truck do I need when moving in Shelter Island?
16' Truck
Most people in Shelter Island need a 16' moving truck. Compare rental trucks and find your perfect size.
Advice for Moving in Shelter Island or Anywhere.
Because we know a little about moving, we've written some need-to-know articles that can help make moving in Shelter Island, or anywhere really, as easy as can be.
Too Big, Too Small, or Just Right — Find the Right Size and Type of Moving Box for Your Move
10 Charities Offering Free Furniture Donation Pickup
What’s the Cheapest Way To Move? A Guide for Thrifty Moving
Empty Nesting: Downsizing and Moving to a Smaller Home
Study: How Much Does Moving Cost in 2023?
Why Do So Many People in Shelter Island Use HireAHelper?
Nobody understands moving in Shelter Island like we do.
HireAHelper curates local movers in Shelter Island that have MC#/DOT licenses and verified user reviews. After we help you easily book your movers, we're here 7 days-a-week to monitor your move for you, both online and with a REAL person over the phone.
And as if that wasn’t enough, we offer personalized insurance policies on every single booking through HireAHelper in New York, so you'll feel extra safe on Moving Day.
1,452 Shelter Island Mover Reviews
On average, movers on HireAHelper earn 4.8 stars out of 5.0 after 293,887 verified customer reviews
EXCELLENT JOB! These three strong and hard working men did a fabulous job. Can’t say enough about them! Professional, polite and friendly. I highly recommend them.
What a GREAT TEAM!! Very hard working crew, we actually had to get moving to direct the job. It happened so fast!! I would recommend Last Minute Movers. Thank you ??
These guys were just great. The Leader was fantastic with organizing everyone and directing a very efficient move out and move it. Nothing was damaged in the PODs because of their professionalism in packing!
The movers were great! They handled my belongings with care and carried things up to the second and third floor without any issues or complaints. The work was done in a reasonable amount of time. Thank you!
The Last Minute team arrived right on time, worked tirelessly and did such an amazing job with unloading our belongings. Would absolutely recommend for moving assistance.
These guys were great, they knew what they were doing and packed the box up quickly. They called to work out the timing. They arrived when they said they would. Very professional people.
They were pleasant, professional, and punctual. When they came across any challenges with the electric systems or appliances, they went the extra distance to figure it out and/or help. I am very grateful to the gentlemen for a job well done.
They were on time, very prepared, very kind and friendly - a pleasure to work with in every way. They were also very flexible in adjusting to a few little hiccups on our end, and didn't make us feel rushed in anyway. Highly recommend these guys.
On time, respectful, efficient and all around pleasant movers. They were very good at fitting as much as possible into small stoarge spaces while still being careful of our furniture. We highly recommend them and will definitely be using them again.
Fantastic, fast and very efficient. Got the whole job done in time with no problems! Would absolutely recommend if you want skilled, professional moving labor help.